Women Who Lead Boldly – The Courage To Lead From Who We Are
SERIES 3: SIGNATURE POST
Our organizations need the perspectives women develop through their lives. Making room for those perspectives requires a broader understanding of authority and the many ways effective leadership can be expressed.
I recall two conversations in my career that made me rise up in defense. Both were with male bosses who believed they were helping me develop as a leader. The first happened when I was relatively new to leadership. My fairly new boss told me I was too opinionated and would get further in my career if I wasn’t so bold.
I immediately heard my ancestors say, “Wake up, girl. Don’t let them put you in a cage.” My immediate response was, “Well, the leaders at this organization whom I respect most are very bold and outspoken.” He asked whom I meant, and I named two very powerful women in the organization. I added that I wondered how they would feel about his advice. He immediately shrank and changed the subject.
The second conversation occurred 25 years later, when my again fairly new boss told me I needed to be more outspoken and charismatic to advance. This time, I recognized the cage immediately. I asked whether he was saying that introverts could not advance in leadership. Again, the familiar backpedaling. What was very interesting about both situations, these two men were my peers for years and never once did they offer their perspective as guidance. It wasn't until they step into a position of authority that they felt compelled to be helpful.
I share these experiences because the struggle is still real. Women continue to encounter outdated assumptions about what leadership should look like, often delivered as helpful advice. It is further complicated when the advice framed as support asks you to let go of the very thing that makes you a differentiated leader. Responding to these pressures requires the courage that enables women to bring the fullness of their strength, experience, and wisdom into leadership.
Courage is required to trust your judgment when the accepted picture of leadership looks different from you. When you are constantly encouraged toward sameness, it takes courage to examine the advice you receive and decide what will help you grow. It also takes discernment to recognize when that advice would diminish a valuable part of your contribution.
Muragishi et al. (2024) investigated whether treatment conveying receptivity to someone’s contributions affected women’s anticipated sense of fit in technology companies. Across four primary experiments, women anticipated greater fit when treated as respected work partners, beyond the effects of simply receiving socially warm treatment. The benefits extended to observing another woman receive this treatment. These findings help explain why the way we receive women’s contributions matters, including in conversations intended to support their development.
So we must muster up the inner strength to speak up, make unpopular decisions, admit uncertainty, and remain open to correction. In doing so, yes we leave ourselves exposed to judgments about whether we are too forceful, too uncertain, or too soft. And I have found that standing in this courage has sharpen my ability to form an opinion, make decisions, evaluate circumstances, people or data with a sense of ownership and boldness. It has been this type of ignorance that has allowed me to trust that my perspective belongs in the room. Knowing this for certain became the foundation for bold leadership for me.
To our disservice, we have bifurcated leadership characteristics into binary roles with masculine perceived as the most effective. Reflecting back on my two bosses, the first was telling me my leadership approach was too agentic or masculine. Where the second was telling me my leadership approach was lacking masculinity. Alice Eagly and Mary Karu's framework (2002) asserts that within our organizations leadership prototypes are historically aligned with masculine traits which continues to be problematic for women.
Gender-role Schema theory helps us understand that this thinking is culturally embedded in how we see the world. Historically, directive or command and control has been coded a masculine. We often associate goals such as accomplishment, winning, and financial growth to this leadership approach. Servant leadership has been coded as feminine with goals such as growth of people, collaboration, and community associated.
Clearly both leadership styles are helpful for leaders managing our organizations. Both women and men can exercise either of these leadership behaviors and be recognized as effective leaders. Therefore we must begin dismantling the dichotomy of these styles and challenge our mental models about the historically associated gender characteristics. We need them both and keeping them bound by psychological constructs of gender limits our ability to fully utilize the talent in our organizations. Sparr, Waldman, and Kearney (2023) helped us understand the necessity for organizations to skill their executives to use both agentic alongside servant leadership behaviors. They argued that like all paradoxes, effectiveness is achieved when both are integrated and held in equal esteem.
Women learn and experience the world through a lens shaped in part by being women. Experiences of opportunity, responsibility, credibility, belonging, and exclusion can influence what we notice and the questions we ask. Race, culture, generation, and circumstance deepen the range of perspectives among women. The wisdom that emerges deserves consideration for what it helps an organization understand. I see an implication for how we develop women leaders: when we encourage them to set aside this wisdom to fit an existing model, we risk leaving valuable contributions unused. Our organizations benefit from recognizing and developing the capabilities people bring.
We should expect our organizations to recognize these capabilities as they help us develop. This is why I assert that we need women leading boldly in our organizations. There is far too much at risk when women apologize for their presence, imitate an accepted model at the expense of their judgment, or shrink to fit in.
I often return to the portrait of a woman in Proverbs 31:10–31. I read this passage as an invitation to bring our judgment, enterprise, generosity, wise speech, strength, and dignity to the families, businesses, and communities of which we are a part. Her influence is expressed through the decisions she makes, the work she undertakes, and the people she supports. The passage offers a rich picture of strength exercised across the responsibilities of a life.
For me, the foundation of that courage is faith. The passage’s emphasis on reverence for God grounds my understanding of where our worth comes from and how we use the gifts entrusted to us. That foundation helps me consider whose expectations I am allowing to shape my leadership. It also encourages me to develop my capabilities and use them responsibly alongside the contributions of others.
It takes courage to stand in one’s authentic self, especially when people who want to help are telling you that you are too much or too different. That pressure can make it harder to question a familiar practice, name a human cost others have overlooked, set a boundary, or make a difficult decision we will have to defend. Courage develops through practice, reflection, and the support we build around us. Organizations have a corresponding responsibility to make room for different expressions of effective leadership.
It starts with examining our own assumptions and pausing when we are asked to change who we are. We can get curious and ask why, consider the evidence, and decide how the advice serves our growth and the work we are responsible for leading. We can also examine the counsel we give other women. Our experience should help expand their possibilities and strengthen their ability to contribute.
As you consider your own leadership, reflect on the wisdom you may have been holding back. What would it take to bring it more fully into your work, and who could support you as you do? The organizations we serve need women who are willing to trust, develop, and use what their lives have taught them to help create organizations people trust. Now that is an invitation worth stepping into boldly.
References
Barthel, A. D. T., & Buengeler, C. (2023). Servant versus directive leadership and promotability: Does leader gender matter? Frontiers in Psychology, 14, Article 957121. https://doi.org/10.3389/fpsyg.2023.957121
Chen, S.-C., & Shao, J. (2022). Feminine traits improve transformational leadership advantage: Investigation of leaders’ gender traits, sex and their joint impacts on employee contextual performance. Gender in Management: An International Journal, 37(5), 569–586. https://doi.org/10.1108/GM-06-2020-0167
Muragishi, G. A., Aguilar, L., Carr, P. B., & Walton, G. M. (2024). Microinclusions: Treating women as respected work partners increases a sense of fit in technology companies. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 126(3), 431–460. https://doi.org/10.1037/pspi0000430
Neubert, M. J., de Luque, M. S., Quade, M. J., & Hunter, E. M. (2022). Servant leadership across the globe: Assessing universal and culturally contingent relevance in organizational contexts. Journal of World Business, 57(2), Article 101268. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jwb.2021.101268
Women Who Lead Boldly
SERIES 3 EPISODES

EPISODE 1
Why Women Lead Differently – And Why That Matters
COMING SOON

EPISODE 2
The Art of Using Your Voice
COMING SOON

EPISODE 3
Mentorship That Transforms
COMING SOON

EPISODE 4
Boundaries, Balance, Brilliance
COMING SOON

